• by woah on 11/5/2019, 5:57:21 PM

    How is it possible that the core is several years younger if the core and the surface have gone around the sun the same number of times?

  • by nyc640 on 11/5/2019, 6:07:11 PM

    Here is a more accessible explanation for those (like me) who are unfamiliar with the maths: https://www.sciencealert.com/earth-s-core-is-2-5-years-young...

  • by tomxor on 11/6/2019, 2:23:29 AM

    > The pedagogical value of this discussion is to show students that any number or observation, no matter who brought it forward, must be critically examined.

    Excellent, I hope this value is also encouraged more in schools now than when I was there.

  • by madengr on 11/5/2019, 5:44:38 PM

    What's the deepest core sample; 10 km? I assume isotope dating is no where near accurate enough to see the difference.

  • by kstrauser on 11/5/2019, 6:21:09 PM

    It seems like it would be the opposite:

    - If you are smack dab in the middle of the Earth, although you'd be mashed, gravitational forces should be equal in all directions and therefore cancel out to zero.

    - Ergo, if you are on the surface of the Earth, gravity should make your clocks run slower than in the middle.

    What am I missing that makes this untrue?

  • by p1esk on 11/5/2019, 6:07:57 PM

    What about the center of a black hole? Is it younger than the surface?

  • by gumby on 11/5/2019, 6:05:01 PM

    This only works because the core is denser than the surface.

    (hint: imagine the limit case where the earth were a hollow sphere)

  • by spuz on 11/5/2019, 6:13:55 PM

    Does the same apply to the Sun? How old is the centre of the Sun compared to its surface?

  • by hirundo on 11/5/2019, 6:36:41 PM

    > Comments: Published version, apart from minor editing (e.g. corrections of 'center' to 'centre')

    > Journal reference: Eur.J.Phys. vol. 37, 035602 (2016)

    If Brexit occurs, Britain will no longer be a European nation, and therefore the European Journal of Physics will no longer be obliged to accept "centre" as the standard spelling of "center", right?

  • by bregma on 11/5/2019, 7:12:04 PM

    It's all a wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey big BIG ball of string.

  • by dashesyan on 11/5/2019, 5:58:54 PM

    There's a "yo momma" joke just waiting to be made here...